Food & Nutrition

Freshpet vs. Ollie: How to Compare the Real Monthly Cost

Compare Freshpet and Ollie using daily feeding cost, monthly spend, storage, introductory offers, and the way you actually feed your dog.

erica erica
October 15, 2026
2 min read

Freshpet vs. Ollie: How to Compare the Real Monthly Cost

Fresh dog food can look expensive or affordable depending on how the price is presented.

The best way to compare Freshpet and Ollie is to calculate what each would actually cost to feed your dog every month.

Compare daily feeding cost

Package prices alone don’t tell you enough.

Estimate how much of each food your dog would eat per day based on the product guidance and your dog’s individual needs.

Multiply that by roughly 30 days.

Now you have a much more useful monthly comparison.

Account for how you use the food

Some pet parents feed fresh food as the full diet.

Others use it as a topper or partial meal.

Those approaches create very different monthly costs.

Compare Freshpet and Ollie based on how you actually plan to use the food.

Consider storage and delivery

Fresh and refrigerated foods require more planning than shelf-stable kibble.

Think about:

  • Refrigerator or freezer space

  • Delivery frequency

  • How quickly opened food needs to be used

  • Convenience

Don’t let a first-order offer decide everything

A strong introductory promotion can lower the first month’s cost.

For a fair comparison, estimate the regular price after that promotion ends.

Check current PetBux offers

Before ordering, see whether the relevant retailer or brand currently participates in PetBux.

RELATED BLOG: Link premium dog food on a budget to the existing relevant PetBux article.

Which is better?

The better choice depends on your dog’s needs, how you plan to feed the product, convenience, and your recurring budget.

If nutrition questions are involved, use your veterinarian as the source for dietary guidance and use this comparison to make the shopping decision.